Harlequins 38 Northampton Saints 31: Tom Vickers' review and player ratings
It was hard to know what to make of Saints’ defeat at the Twickenham Stoop on Saturday.
On one hand, it really didn’t matter, because top spot was already secured going into the game, rendering the result meaningless.


On the other hand, no one of a black, green and gold persuasion will ever be apathetic about a defeat, especially one that came so late on, in such controversial fashion and after Saints really should have wrapped the game up in the minutes before Tom Lawday dived over to win it for Harlequins.
The try could easily have been ruled out, but TMO Hamish Smales decided that Marcus Smith’s pass in the build-up hadn’t gone forward, despite the cut of the grass very much suggesting otherwise as the ball went from one shade of green to another.
After advice from Smales, referee Craig Maxwell-Keys green-lighted the try, giving Smith the chance to stick the boot in as he added the gloss of the conversion.
For Saints, it was a game that very much got away, as they had been leading 31-24 late on and then had their own chances to win it after Quins levelled things up at 31-31.
But in a real roller coaster affair, the away side were the ones who hit a trough as Quins peaked in the final seconds.
It showed the danger of becoming embroiled in a you-score-we-score battle as any team in the Gallagher PREM is capable of upsetting the odds late on.
Both sides really failed to get any persistent momentum in a match in which they both struggled in key areas.
For Quins, it was at the set piece as they were undone time and again at the lineout, while also shipping penalties at scrum time.
For Saints, it was at the breakdown, where they were continually penalised and continually lost possession.
That meant that even when they took the lead, they couldn’t hold on to it and hammer home their superiority.
Saints conceded a try at the end of both halves, which ultimately proved extremely costly.
However, it must be said that when Lawday landed the decisive blow, the black, green and gold had reshuffled their back line to preserve Tom Litchfield, Fraser Dingwall and James Ramm as they have far bigger fish to fry this week.
They ended the game with George Hendy, typically a wing or full-back, at centre and Jonny Weimann, who started at scrum-half, on the wing.
Still though, they could easily have won this game.
And for a club with such high standards, one which has scored a PREM record 104 tries this season and won 14 of their 18 league encounters, they would have expected to have got it over the line.
It’s hard to know how much they will make of the defeat, but there is no doubt they can take key lessons from it ahead of a huge PREM play-off semi-final at home to Leicester Tigers on Friday.
The breakdown was clearly the biggest area of focus post-match, and Saints know they will have to show vast improvement there against a Tigers team who are extremely good at stemming the tide by stealing the ball.
Tommy Reffell’s eyes will have lit up while watching the footage of this match, and Saints, a team that thrive on fast ball and attacking momentum, really need to find a way to sustain pressure better than they did against Harlequins.
They had a pack more than capable of taking them to victory at the Twickenham Stoop, but they were unable to keep their foot on the throat of a Quins team who presented them with chances to.
And they know that if they can’t find some control amid the chaos this week then Tigers will happily accept the invite to spoil the Gardens party.
How they rated…
JAMES PATER – showcased his flowing running style on a couple of occasions as he kept Quins on their toes and he showed bravery in bouncing back from a couple of big hits during the first half… 6
JAMES MARTIN – things didn’t really click for the wing on this occasion, but it was a tough ask to come into a PREM game having not played of late… 5.5
TOM LITCHFIELD – some typically strong running from the centre during the first half as Quins struggled to stop him in his stride… 6.5
FRASER DINGWALL – the skipper led a break for a try during the first period and he did everything he had to in assured fashion, as ever… 7
JAMES RAMM – will have been delighted to get some minutes under his belt and he played his part in some decent moves… 6.5
ANTHONY BELLEAU – never lets the team down and he did little wrong overall as he kept his team moving and stood tall in defence… 6.5
JONNY WEIMANN – CHRON STAR MAN – a really promising performance from the scrum-half. He scored two tries, helped to set the tone for his team with some good tempo and even held his own on the wing… 8
DANILO FISCHETTI – saw a couple of passes slip through his grasp but did his job at scrum time as Saints put pressure on Harlequins… 6.5
CURTIS LANGDON – a strong return to action from the hooker. Saints will be so happy to have him back, and he battled on after suffering a nasty forehead cut during the first half… 7
CLEOPAS KUNDIONA – a good shift from the tighthead, who is another welcome returnee from injury. He cranked up the heat on Quins in the scrum… 7
TOM LOCKETT – helped Saints to disrupt the Quins lineout and he was a steady presence in the second row, as ever… 7
JJ VAN DER MESCHT – got through the full 80 minutes and he was tough to handle at times, notching a try during the first half… 7.5
JOSH KEMENY – grabbed a score and was a menace in the lineout as Quins struggled to secure the ball in that area… 7
TOM PEARSON – thundered around the field in trademark fashion and was hungry to make an impact… 7
SAM GRAHAM – didn’t really get a chance to make an impact on this match as he was forced off after just eight minutes as he had to undergo a head injury assessment
Replacements (who played more than 20 minutes)
CALLUM CHICK (for Graham 8) – was in the thick of the action, particularly during the first half, as he showed his importance to the team once again… 8
TOBY THAME (for Litchfield 52) – excellent awareness and execution from the centre as he grabbed a second half try with a lovely kick ahead and gather… 7
TOM WEST (for Fischetti 52) – got through his work and will have benefitted from this game time… 6
GEORGE HENDY (for Dingwall 57) – didn’t get a chance to showcase his running game as he slotted in at centre, but didn’t look out of place in that position… 6